Skip to main content

Paul’s house churches in Rome, September 13th, 2026

September 13, 2026
Paul’s house churches in Rome, September 13th, 2026

Paul’s house churches in Rome

SERMON SEPTEMBER 13, 2026, THE SIXTEENTH SUNDAY AFTER PENTECOST

ROMANS 14:1-12

 

From the Epistle: If we live, we live to the Lord, and if we die, we die to the Lord… whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord’s.

Paul addresses the churches in Rome in 56-58 CE. These were an unknown number of well-established households of Jesus Christ, which met in large houses or apartments. Possibly up to 100 people at a time met in these churches. Though they did not have dedicated buildings for their life together, they had leadership and habits of worship. We can assume that, as faithful Christians, they also did work among the poor of the community, loving their neighbor as themselves.

This structure parallels the structure of the faith movement Jesus initiated, 30 years earlier, when he sent out his disciples two-by-two, into all the town and villages where he would later go himself. Where Jesus’ disciples found a welcoming home, they in effect created an embryonic house church, which Jesus would ground more firmly when he arrived.

So, in this model of evangelism and church planting, Paul later would go to Rome, and be a presence among the local churches. However, there was a major difference. When Paul arrived in Rome he was a prisoner, having been arrested in Jerusalem about 60 CE.

The Christians in Rome, to whom Paul had been writing, came out to meet him south of the city, along the Appian Way as he arrived. While in Rome, Paul was under house arrest for two years with a guard, receiving all who came to visit him. So, although he could not go to the house churches, they could come to him, and they did.

Christians were hassled in Rome, and in fact around 49 CE the Emperor Claudius ordered all Jews to leave the city. This included Jewish Christians. Those gentile Christians who remained were social outcasts. A few years later, after Claudius died, the expulsion edict lapsed and Jews were permitted to return to Rome.

What this meant for the house churches is that habits and decisions and leadership had come to reside with the gentile Christians who remained in Rome. When Jewish church members returned, all of these needed to be renegotiated. Church politics then clustered around Torah, circumcision, food, holy days, Abraham, Israel, and the relationship between Jews and Gentiles in God’s purposes. Paul addresses these stresses throughout his letter to the Romans.

Paul had to remind people that church members have different approaches, and that these could coexist within the same church body. I just used the term, “church politics.” That sends shivers down our timbers, doesn’t it? But it doesn’t have to. My sense is that our church politics here at St. Francis pale in relation to our desire for oneness. I’d much rather be able to enjoy the person down the row of chairs in church, but who has some opinions that differ from mine, than to have to worry about whether I have to sit next to that person. This is exactly the tack Paul takes when writing to the Romans.

He selects dietary habits as one source of friction within the churches: not for the purpose of quarreling over opinions. Some believe in eating anything, while the weak eat only vegetables. What does this mean? For an observant Jewish Christian, buying meat in pagan Rome could present serious problems. Was the animal kosher? Had it been slaughtered properly? Had blood been removed? Had the meat been associated with pagan sacrifice? The simplest way to skirt all these issues is simply not to eat meat. Paul’s conclusion:

Those who eat must not despise those who abstain, and those who abstain must not pass judgment on those who eat; for God has welcomed them. Who are you to pass judgment on servants of another? It is before their own lord that they stand or fall. And they will be upheld, for the Lord is able to make them stand.

The Episcopal Church used to have knock’em-down-drag’em-out fights over the Prayer Book before the 1928 BCP was superseded by the present 1979 BCP. But in some parishes, it took a while to settle down, and it was not uncommon for many years to find a middle way of worshiping in Episcopal parishes: according the 1928 BCP at the early service, and the 1979 Book at the main service.

Episcopalians used to fight over high church or low church ways of worshiping. High church means looking/sounding/smelling/feeling more like Roman Catholic worship. Low church means engaging the senses less, leaving a degree of simplicity in the conduct and setting of worship, more in keeping with a Protestant ethic. So questions arise: Where should the altar be? Facing East or facing the congregation? How many signs of the cross are made and how about genuflecting versus a simple bow to the cross? How about incense? A high church uses incense every Sunday, whereas a low church never uses it and a middle way is to use incense on high holy days. I would use incense on occasion if someone would show me where the censor and incense are! There are solid reasons for any of these stances. And there is no reason to fight. We all worship the same God.

One of two most serious ruptures in the Episcopal Church came early in this century, when Gene Robinson was elected bishop of the Diocese of New Hampshire, the first openly gay Episcopal bishop. He served for ten years ending in 2013. His ordination was a milestone for the Episcopal Church, and was the impetus for a number of parishes to withdraw from the Episcopal Church and become American Anglican parishes.

My husband, The Rev. Dr. David Pollock, and I witnessed this structural division when we lived in Nigeria. The Most Rev. Peter Jasper Akinola, retired Primate of the Anglican Province of Nigeria, became the bishop who supervised some of these American Anglican parishes. He would not permit David to exercise his priesthood, or visit the local Anglican priest, or work with church women in the villages – simply because of his Episcopal affiliation. And as for me exercising my priesthood: that was out of the question, because not only was I Episcopalian, but I also was a female priest.

A similar thing occurred in 1974 when the Episcopal Church began ordaining women to the priesthood, which happened extra-judicially in the case of the Philadelphia Eleven. These women were ordained outside of canon law because many Episcopalians felt it was high time for this to be, and General Convention was moving too slowly. Two years later, General Convention approved the ordination of women. Later, in 1989, The Rt. Rev. Barbara Harris was ordained as the first female Episcopal Bishop. And not only was she a woman, but she was also Black.

Our diocesan bishop, the Rt. Rev. Sarah Fisher, crosses both of these boundaries, being both gay and female. Since she is not alone in crossing them, gender and sexuality are boundaries to ordination no more. We are blessed by her episcopal presence among us, and we are eager to have her visit St. Francis on our patronal festival, St. Francis Day, October 4th.

Through all of these controversies, Paul keeps his eye on the target: who are we to judge another? he says. Each one of us stands before God, and God is our judge. And God has welcomed us all. Jesus has died and been resurrected for the world. Standing at the empty tomb: meat or vegetables, gay or straight, woman or man, 1928 BCP or 1979 Prayer Book – all of these become clear in perspective.

What counts is the love of God for each creature. We know and trust the love of God for St. Francis Church. God’s love is bountiful, overflowing, tender, forgiving. This love is mediated through worship, through Holy Scripture and tradition and God-given reason. By grace, may we please God in all we think, do or say.

THANKS BE TO GOD. Amen.